Mirjam Neelen & P.A. Kirschner
What does it take to become an expert? According to the influential deliberate practice theory, achieving expert performance requires a vast amount of deliberate practice. The term “deliberate practice” is used abundantly in the world of learning and education. However, as with many ‘magic words’ (Learning analytics! Grit! Mindset!), they are often incorrectly understood, explained, and/or applied (and sometimes they’re just plain nonsense).
Deliberate practice versus ‘just practice’
Patti Shank, well-known learning expert, researcher, and writer wrote a blog on deliberate practice back in May 2016 where she points out that people who are trying to improve their level of expertise set specific goals to improve their skills. However, in order for this practice to be ‘deliberate’ it actually needs to be taken a number of steps further.
According to Anders Ericsson (1993), who coined the term and has researched it for over 30 years, refers to deliberate practice as practice activities that maximise improvement throughout development toward expert performance. The key word here is expert! He’s not talking about being or becoming proficient or doing something well, but rather becoming an expert in something; being the best at something. Because constant individual instruction is too costly or not feasible, the teacher or coach must design practice activities that the individual can engage in between meetings with her/him.
Ericsson’s explanation clearly shows that deliberate practice is not simply practising something that you want to do better. Deliberate practice is extremely targeted. Each practise session should focus on something that you are almost able to do but not just yet. First, it must be very clear what you want to achieve and that whatever it is, it is to become an expert/topper in that area, whether it is tennis, playing the violin, or surgery. Second, the learning path has to be constantly monitored and adapted for your current level and the next level after that (think here of Vygotsky’s zone of proximal development). The learning tasks and assignments consistently need to be designed so that you can take it one step further than your current level. This idea is very similar to Jeroen van Merriënboer’s 4C/ID design model and is explained in detail in Ten Steps to Complex Learning (Kirschner & Van Merriënboer, 2008, 2012). Next, extremely targeted practice, as deliberate practice is, requires large amounts of internal motivation. After all, you have to be willing to put in the required effort and make the necessary sacrifices to become the best. And last but not least, you need an experienced and knowledgeable teacher or coach to give you the effective feedback to optimise effectively and efficiently maximise your performance.
Shank also mentions the need for feedback from an expert as well as the need to get out of one’s comfort zone. We would like to add that the learner needs to put in serious, consistent effort and, for example give up certain habits or make certain sacrifices (e.g., going out, eating and not eating certain things, sacrificing much if not all free time, etc.). In other words: sweat alone isn’t enough; blood and tears are required as well. OK, of course this is a slight exaggeration, however it makes the point clear. To become an expert takes a lot more than ‘just practice’.
Why ‘just practice’ doesn’t make you an expert
So, why is ‘just’ regular practice not enough to gain expertise? Why can we not just practise for the 10,000 hours that Malcolm Gladwell mentioned in his book Outliers? The key is that practice in itself isn’t enough. It’s far and foremost about how you practise and how you are coached within that practice. In a recent Freakonomics podcast, Ericsson says the following about Gladwell’s 10,000 hours rule:
“Now, right. Gladwell basically thought that was kind of an interesting magical number and suggested that the key here is to reach that 10,000 hours. I think he’s really done something very important, helping people see the necessity of this extended training period before you reach high levels of performance. But I think there’s really nothing magical about 10,000 hours. Just the amount of experience performing may in fact have very limited chances to improve your performance. The key seems to be that deliberate practice, where you’re actually working on improving your own performance — that is the key process, and that’s what you need to try to maximize.”
When you’ve reached a certain level, you can ‘design’ your own learning activities as well. Shank explains that over time people need to be able to self-monitor their skills, find the mistakes, and adjust (i.e., they must self-regulate their learning). Many articles on workplace learning claim that professionals or knowledge workers are well able to do this. Well, you might be an expert in your field but that doesn’t necessarily make you an expert learner nor an expert in designing your own learning experiences. Shank’s warning makes sense. If you expect people to self-monitor too quickly, before they are able, they are lost.
This is also a reminder that, although you do learn while doing your job and working with others, it’s not the same as practise. It’s work. Shank points out that one of the reasons that ‘normal’ work doesn’t necessarily make us better is that the prerequisites such as specific goals and meaningful expert feedback are not there. Shank says:
“Rather than improve, we simply do what we usually do. We aren’t inclined to move out of our comfort zone during these times, for fear of making mistakes and looking stupid. In fact, we are likely on “autopilot” because we can’t take the time to slow down and “practise.”
This is exactly the point, and there’s more. It’s not just about making mistakes. Deliberate practice also means that you (yourself or with help from others) manage to ‘catch’ the mistakes that you make and which impede your achieving perfection/expertise and then find a way to eliminate them. If you don’t do that, you’re “just practising”. Regular practice can be extremely important sometimes. For example, if you need to master a certain procedure or be able to do something faster; that is, to become very proficient at something. However, through this type of practice you don’t achieve (a next level of) expertise or excellence!
Deliberate practice and what else it takes to achieve expertise
It’s clear that becoming an expert is not something that can be achieved over night. In her June 2016 blog, Shank points out that even deliberate practice is most likely not enough! She summarises a meta-analysis (88 studies, 11,135 participants) conducted by Brooke Macnamara and colleagues who found that individual differences, such as intelligence and specific abilities, have an impact on expertise growth as well.
After its publication, Ericsson criticised the meta-analysis. Interestingly, one of his main criticisms is that Macnamara and her fellow authors do not define deliberate practice the correct way. Ericsson claims that they use the term deliberate practice to refer to a much broader and less defined concept. He basically says that they sum up every hour of any type of practice, which would imply that the impact of all types of practice activity on performance are equal. Ericsson goes on to say that this assumption is inconsistent with the evidence.
Macnamara c.s. has, in turn responded to Ericsson’s criticism. They claim that Ericsson’s definition of deliberate practice refers to “those training activities that were designed solely for the purpose of improving individuals’ performance by a teacher or the performers themselves” (p. 84). Therefore, they argue, deliberate practice could be designed by a teacher/coach or the performers themselves.
This debate is fascinating because it shows that the interpretation of what deliberate practice actually is, seems to be ‘all over the place’. Until everyone gets on the same page on what is and what isn’t deliberate practice, identifying the its role in achieving expertise compared to other ‘expertise drivers’ seems challenging to say the least. Can the true expert on this matter please rise?
Ericsson, K.A., (1993). The Role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Psychological Review, 100, 363-406. Retrieved from http://projects.ict.usc.edu/itw/gel/EricssonDeliberatePracticePR93.PDF.
Ericsson, K. A. (2016). Summing up hours of any type of practice versus identifying optimal practice activities: Comments on Macnamara, Moreau, and Hambrick (2015). Perspectives on Psychological Science, 11, 351–354. Retrieved from http://pps.sagepub.com/content/11/3/351.abstract.
Ericsson, K. A., & Pool, R., (2016). Peak. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/1099221/peak/9781847923196/.
Gladwell, M., (2009). Outliers: The story of success. Boston, MA: Little, Brown and Company.
Kirschner, P. A., (2016, June). De klok horen luiden (1): Deliberate practice. [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.didactiefonline.nl/blog-paul-kirschner/12828-de-klok-horen-luiden-1-deliberate-practice.
Kirschner, P. A., & Van Merriënboer, J. J. G, (2008). Ten steps to complex learning a new approach to instruction and instructional design. In T. L. Good (Ed.), 21st Century Education: A Reference Handbook (Chapter 26, pp. 244–253). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Macnamara, B.N., Hambrick, D.Z., & Moreau, D., (2016). How Important Is Deliberate Practice? Reply to Ericsson (2016). Perspectives on Psychological Science, 11, 355-358. Retrieved from http://scottbarrykaufman.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Macnamara-et-al.-2016-Reply-to-Ericsson.pdf.
Macnamara, B. N., Hambrick, D. Z., and Oswald, F. L. (2014). Deliberate practice and performance in music, games, sports, education, and professions: a meta-analysis. Psychological Science, 25, 1608-1618. Retrieved from http://scottbarrykaufman.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/Macnamara-et-al.-2014.pdf.
Shank, P., (2016, May 26). Science of Learning 101: What kind of practice makes expert? [Web log post]. Retrieved from https://www.td.org/Publications/Blogs/Science-of-Learning-Blog/2016/05/Science-of-Learning-101-What-Kind-of-Practice-Makes-Expert.
Shank, P., (2016, June 8). What do you know: How fast can we achieve expertise? [Web log post]. Retrieved from https://www.td.org/Publications/Blogs/Science-of-Learning-Blog/2016/06/What-Do-You-Know-How-Fast-Can-We-Achieve-Expertise?platform=hootsuite.
Van Merriënboer, J. J. G., & Kirschner, P. A., (2012). Ten Steps to Complex Learning. Abingdon, PLAATS: Routledge.
23 thoughts on “Deliberate Practice: What it is and what it isn’t”
Reblogged this on onderwijs_2032 science check and commented:
The deliberate practice secrets of expertise are fascinating. How does it translate to educational practice? See Ericsson & Pool ‘Peak’, the closing chapter ‘Where do we go from here’? (Wieman’s experiment). Deserves more attention.
Reblogged this on From experience to meaning… and commented:
Great post by Mirjam & Paul!
Great blog – thanks for paying attention to this fascinating topic in this well documented way. I want to add a remark and a personal story. The addition is the role of rest. Ericcson also mentions this in his research: it seems important to plan deliberate practice and rest rather precisely. To much deliberate practice each day seems to lead to ‘over training’ thus giving worse results. My personal story is about a top drummer (expert!) Thomas Lang whom I met twice. Thomas Lang works/worked with lots of famous artist and started his career as the drummer of the Austrian band ‘Falco’. During a masterclass Lang shared one of his principles: ‘never practice when you play and never play when you practice’ that learned me about the nature of deliberate practice. Indeed he explained that practice is about trying to master a technique (riff) that you do not master yet or not yet in a smooth enough way. This means it will be frustrating, you’ll experience that you fail. At these moments you’ll be seduced to lett go the practice and play a piece that you already master – because its more fun and rewarding, it confirms that you can do something well. Thomas Lang warned not to play at that moment and stick to the practice. As an amateur drummer (at that time) that did resonate with me. The other part of his advice is that when performing on stage- an artist must not practice but play: there you have to deliver results. What puzzels me about deliberate practice related to workplace learning is how many people get (and need) time for Deliberate Practice in our fast paced world. I think not enough or don’t we need experts any more? Please share your thoughts.
Hi Ger, thanks for sharing your story! I think your question about time for deliberate practice in the workplace is a very good question indeed. I do think we need experts more than ever, to be honest. I need to think about it but promise I will get back to you about it.
I have been browsing on-line more than three hours these days,
but I by no means discovered any attention-grabbing article like yours.
It is beautiful worth enough for me. In my view, if all site owners and bloggers made excellent content material as you did,
the net might be much more helpful than ever before. http://www.yahoo.net
Thanks for the great and beautiful endorsement. Spread the word please!!
Reblogged this on The Echo Chamber.
Thankfulness to my father who told me on the topic of this website, this weblog is actually
Good way of explaining, and good paragraph to obtain facts concerning my
presentation focus, which i am going to convey in university. https://www.youstar.community/groups/the-little-known-secrets-to-car-games/
I do not know if it’s just me or if everyone else experiencing problems
with your website. It looks like some of the text within your posts are running off the screen. Can somebody else please comment and let me know if this is happening to
them as well? This could be a issue with my browser because I’ve had this happen before.
Thank you http://Www.casilloadvogados.com.br/
I’m really sorry you’re experiences problems with our blog. I have done the following (not sure if any of it is helpful so please let me know):
1. Checked the blog in Chrome, Firefox, and IE. For me, the text looked fine in all 3 browers.
2. Checked the WordPress support site for issues with browsers. This is one of the notes: A note about Internet Explorer: Due to browser incompatibility, some themes are not fully functional in Internet Explorer 10 or earlier. If you are using Internet Explorer 10 or below we recommend upgrading your browser for an optimal experience. Not sure what browser you are using?
3. Could you please check this website and make sure you have the latest version of whatever browser you’re using? https://browsehappy.com/.
Reblogged this on The Maths Mann.
Hi it’s me, I am also visiting this website daily, this web
page is actually good and the users are actually sharing pleasant thoughts.
I really appreciate how you mentioned that deliberate practice is crucial because it allows you to increase the difficulty of your practice so it can be adapted to our current and next levels. I would agree that this is especially important in sports, in that you should always be challenging yourself and raising the bar so you can become capable of harder tasks. My friend loves to play baseball, and really wants to make the team this year. I’m sure he’d really benefit from finding some batting training weights that he can increase in weight over time so his throwing and hitting velocity can become stronger and so his skills can be honed.
Can I smply just say what a comfort to uncover somebody who actually knows what
they are talking aabout on the web. You definitely know how too brring an issue to
light and make it important. More peeople should looik at this and understand
this side of the story. It’s surprising you aren’t more
popular given that you definitely possess the gift.
Thanks for the compliment!